The knotty tale of famed plaintiffs lawyer Stanley Chesley’s fall from grace has been exhaustively chronicled over the years. But his personal saga took another unexpected turn late Friday night, when home invaders robbed him and his wife, U.S. District Judge Susan Dlott, at gunpoint in the couple’s pricy home near Cincinnati.

As the Cincinnati Enquirer reported, three men allegedly kicked in a basement door of Chesley and Dlott’s house in the affluent suburb of Indian Hill, Ohio, and threatened to shoot Chesley and Dlott. The intruders then allegedly ordered Chesley and Dlott around their house, taking items along the way.