The latest bellwether trial in the General Motors ignition switch litigation has gone in the automaker’s favor, after a verdict was handed up in a Manhattan federal courtroom.

Plaintiff Dennis Ward’s suit against GM, in which he alleged that a faulty ignition switch in his 2009 Chevrolet HHR caused him to rear-end another vehicle in 2014 in Tucson, Arizona, was the seventh bellwether trial and the third in which a jury found for the defendant.