In his opening statement, Apple lawyer Harold McElhinny of Morrison & Foerster told the jury on Wednesday that Samsung should fork over nearly $380 million for 13 infringing devices. Tacked onto what Samsung already owes, that would leave Apple with slightly less than the $1.05 billion award it was granted by a jury last year.

But when it was his turn to address the jury, Samsung lawyer William Price shot for a much steeper discount.